locked PayPal account (SDN list)
Thread poster: Rosa Diez Tagarro
I don't know if any of you may have have received a message from PayPal informing you that your PayPal account has been denied because your name is similar to or a match to an entry on the Office of Foreign Assets Control Specially Designated Nationals (SDN) list.
This has just happened to me and I am astonished. I have checked the above-mentioned list and seen there is one "Rosa Isabel Díaz" in it, a Colombian citizen, apparently.
I do not know if either PayPal or the Department of Treasury are aware that "Díaz" is an extremely common surname in Spanish-speaking countries (and, anyway, my surname is not "Díaz" but "Diez", and I'm not Colombian, BTW, but Spanish).
If somebody on that list was called "Rosa Diez Tagarro" just like me, and was born in Spain, just like me, then I would be able to understand the request for verification of identity I have been sent.
They tell me to send a number of confidential documents to prove I am not the above-mentioned person. They request a utility bill, for instance, which is something that is not that wise to show to anybody, since it contains bank detais, for instance. And a copy of my passport, and a document that proves my date and place of birth...
I would like to know other opinions on this, because it doesn't make sense to me. I mean, you check all the Hispanic and Arab names in the list and realise it is not only you that are in trouble. Many names in it are going to "match" PayPal customers' names, particularly when the criteria for the matches does not seem to be very specific.
I will not go into the reasons why I am not going to send any proof of identification to PayPal, since I don't want this post to be considered political.
I will simply forget about PayPal (I hardly use it anyway).
Any opinions on this matter will be very welcome!
Enjoy the rest of the weekend:
PS: I've just realised this might be the wrong forum and I should have posted on "Money Matters" instead. My apologies, I guess only moderators can move this post to the right place now.
[Edited at 2005-01-29 18:15]
| || || |
| Calumnia de Colombia! || Jan 29, 2005 |
Rosa. You must consult a lawyer. Though it is you who are 'publishing' the libel by drawing attention to it, there are negligence - completely different name - defamatory and credit-denigrating aspects of this lockout.
| | Elena Petelos
Local time: 00:37
English to Greek
| Safer....:-) || Jan 30, 2005 |
A couple of months ago, my account was frozen, as I had two substancial payments from an unverified buyer, that I attempted to transfer into my bank account, thus by far exceeding my monthly transfer limit. The funds were returned to the sender and I was asked for several documents (utility bill, passport copy and bank statement), which I faxed along with paypal's special coversheet. They also emailed asking me to complete three steps: confirm the amounts of two Direct Debit payments from paypal into my account, supply a code they send to me in a letter at my registered address and change my password through my designated email account. The whole thing took approximately 10 working days.
It was difficult to get through to the customer services the first time I called to see if they had received the documents (the last thing they requested), as had to wait for 20 minutes, but I got through immediately the second time I called. The account was back in order an hour after I talked to them, 2 days after I had completed all of the steps mentioned above. It was slightly frustrating at the time, however, in retrospect, I feel safer as they take the trouble to monitor transactions and properly check the identity of account holders. Any bank would, and I think we should expect no less from what effectively is an internet banking facility.
Forgot to mention I checked all the forums at the time, most had complaints from people that had not received their items from ebay. Never heard of anyone loosing money. Also, the FSA regulates paypal, but I assume that's for the UK only...
[Edited at 2005-01-30 04:06]
| || || |
| | lien
Local time: 01:37
English to French
| Thanks for sharing your views || Jan 30, 2005 |
I guess I have to consider myself lucky because this has happened when there was no money in my account, as Burrel says.
I have to say, though, that I have only accepted very small (and very few) payments through PayPal and have always transferred the money to my bank account as soon as it was received.
I had read about PayPalsucks and visited their page, lien. I had also read many positive opinions from Prozians. I have had my account for over 18 months and never experienced any problem at all until yesterday. But I certainly made sure there was never a lot of money to be lost there.
What really amazes me is the (negligent) use they make of the SDN list. I don't think it makes PayPal safer for users, Elena. I think their safety procedures are really arbitrary (think of Elizabeth's case) and, as Tom says, negligent.
Have a nice Sunday evening!