Ask the Asker
Thread poster: Lancashireman
Has anyone else noticed a trend towards ‘special pleading’ in the ‘Ask the Asker’ box? Comments such as “See my added note below ... hope it helps!” sound ingratiating. An answer once posted has unlimited space below where supporting notes may be added, so it is unfair on other contributors to use the neutral ground of the AtA box to exert pressure on the Asker.
| You are right || Mar 26, 2005 |
It's forbidden by KudoZ rules:
I'd say that rule 4.4 "Encouraging others to agree with your answers or disagree with answers provided by others, is prohibited." is the one that should be used here, even it's inteneded for peer agreement.
In case you see such a use of the Ask the asker box, contact the moderator.
| | mstkwasa
Local time: 19:22
English to Japanese
| Using AtA post-grading || Mar 27, 2005 |
In JP>EN and EN>JP pairs, there have been somewhat intemperate discussions using AtA recently while the question was open, bordering on the infringement of rule 4.4.
What galls me even more is the use of AtA after the asker had graded the question. There was a case where one of the answerers whose suggestion was not picked, claiming xx years of residence in the country, quibbled about the asker's decision using AtA and thereby cast aspersion on the chosen answerer's and asker's linguistic abilities - two others and I agreed with the suggestion that was picked so indirectly my colleagues' and my abilities were doubted. This is surely against rule 3.4!
[Edited at 2005-03-27 22:59]
| | writeaway
Local time: 20:22
Partial member (2003)
French to English
| Some are using the Ask the Asker box to "reign" over the question || Mar 28, 2005 |
On one of the sites I participate in, one person routinely uses the Ask the Asker box to make pronouncements about answers given, state his/her own opinions, ideas, comments and often enters into dialogue with Asker as though the question only concerned the two of them. Answers given then must have this person's seal of approval (instead of just agree, one sees 'this is correct', or 'this is what I use' etc.).
I think that (unfortunately) it may be necessary to make an addition to the Kudoz rules in order to stop this sort of behaviour.
| | Lancashireman
Local time: 19:22
German to English
Well, I took the advice of the two moderators here and contacted the two moderators for the board where the ‘special pleading’ took place. One has replied to the effect that no rule appears to have been violated but urges me to propose wording for an amendment to the rules.
So here it is:
4.4 - Encouraging others to agree with your answers or disagree with answers provided by others, is prohibited. The 'Ask the Asker' box must be used only to request further information or context and may not be used to solicit support for any answers provided below.
To report site rules violations or get help, contact a site moderator:
You can also contact site staff by submitting a support request »