Off topic: Why are translations used by big businesses so poor?
Thread poster: Eng2Span
| | Eng2Span
Local time: 15:02
English to Spanish
First of all, just wanted to say that I started visiting Proz a couple of weeks ago and have just been thrilled with this place!
The subject of my post is a bit of a rant to big businesses here in the States... seeing how exceptional the translations are from just about everybody on this site... forces me to wonder where do the big companies here get their translators? If you live in the States, you know what I'm talking about... the phone company, banks, even McDonald's reaching out to Hispanics... yet plagued with really poor Spanish.
Maybe we should send these guys a link... KudoZ to all!
| | Sol
Local time: 15:02
Spanish to English
| bad translations in the U.S. || May 7, 2004 |
If you live in the States, you know what I'm talking about... the phone company, banks, even McDonald's reaching out to Hispanics... yet plagued with really poor Spanish.
My theory is that they are not willing to pay for it. They probably get the same kids that work in their restaurants for minimum wage to do it.
[Edited at 2004-05-08 22:14]
| | Lucinda
Local time: 16:02
Dutch to English
they want to sit in the front row for peanuts or even for free if possible.
As someone said, perhaps they have the kids that work in the restaurants translate the signs instead of having a professional do it.
The fees that they are willing to pay are just so much lower. You get what you pay for.
| Part ignorance, part economics, but not everywhere! || May 7, 2004 |
I think that part of the problem is due to the fact that a lot of respectable business people here still believe that any bilingual person can do translations, so they just give the jobs to their secretaries, waiters and the sort. These same business people also react with surprise when confronted with the rates of a professional translator, since they never thought about it as a profession similar to others like graphic designer, librarian, etc. Thus, there is a certain tendency to try to save money on this field.
However, in my experience, MOST of the business people here mind a lot about the QUALITY of the services/attention they offer their customers, and the ones that realize that good language standards constitute an essential part of their business, look for professional translators and are willing to pay the price. Several of my clients are an example of this.
I guess some fast-food companies are just more interested in catering to the buds, rather than to the eyes, of their Hispanic clientele.
My two cents.
[Edited at 2004-05-07 20:01]
[Edited at 2004-05-09 00:22]
| || || |
| The problem is not confined to the USA alone || May 8, 2004 |
It is seen everywhere. The problem is, translation is not recognized as a serious economic activity. If you see the bar chart of an organization dealing with its clients' projects, whose language is different, there is no provision in the bar chart for the time required for the translation. Nor is there a separate allocation for translations in the budget. The attempt is always there to accommodate this expenditure in the 3% contingencies. As a result, a client coming to a translator always sets unreasonable deadlines and is painfully surprised to hear the prices demanded. The tendency is always to make do with a cheap translation done in haste.
And the funny translations abound. There are quite a number of Proz threads citing such translations.
| Money makes the world go round (or stay put) || May 8, 2004 |
I was recently approached for one of the best projects I have ever been offered and it was for a long term collaboration paid by the hour with a certain number of hours per week. Well I offered my fees and they offered theirs, and then I offered something inbetween and they came back to me saying they would pass the job to their branch in the States since they knew it was going to be so much cheaper.... I don't regret it.
Cheap labour is something of the past.
In many cases, translations for secondary markets are done to meet an internal or external requirement, not because there's a manager who feels it is important to provide a good document.
A known provider that delivers in time is probably all they need. Why risk it if nobody cares?
To report site rules violations or get help, contact a site moderator:
You can also contact site staff by submitting a support request »
Why are translations used by big businesses so poor?
|PerfectIt consistency checker|
|Faster Checking, Greater Accuracy|
PerfectIt helps deliver error-free documents. It improves consistency, ensures quality and helps to enforce style guides. It’s a powerful tool for pro users, and comes with the assurance of a 30-day money back guarantee.
More info »
|You’re a freelance translator? LSP.expert helps you manage your daily translation jobs. It’s easy, fast and secure.|
How about you start tracking translation jobs and sending invoices in minutes? You can also manage your clients and generate reports about your business activities. So you always keep a clear view on your planning, AND you get a free 30 day trial period!
More info »