XML and the Translator
Thread poster: Michael Beijer
| | Michael Beijer
Local time: 03:51
Dutch to English
I basically have two questions:
What will XML mean to those of us who are not necessarily working in localisation?
SDL, Swordfish, etc., seem to be gravitating toward its use. However, almost everything I translate is in Word .doc's. So wouldn't it be better to simply stick to the old-fashioned Workbench (uncleaned/bilingual file) format? A lot of people seem to be complaining that SDL Studio is having serious problems converting their files back into Word .doc's from Studio's new bilingual format: .sdlxliff.
Wouldn't it be better if SDL split their focus into two directions:
1. bilingual .doc for Word documents (MS Word-based workflow)
2. .sdlxliff for file formats with tags (new bilingual format)
After all, SDL is forcing a break with all of the translators out there (and their agencies!) who were/are comfortable with the MS Word-based workflow. Also, said workflow is actually a very pleasant and useful workflow between the translator + proofreader + agency.
Can anyone suggest a good (preferably free) XML viewer/editor? As XML is becoming increasingly prevalent, I would like to start looking into its structure. (I presently am using Notepad++).
See: 'XML and the Translator', by Alan K. Melby, Ph.D. (http://accurapid.com/journal/12xml.htm)
| || |
| No other way... || May 9, 2010 |
Sorry, but bilingual doc/rtf files are a thing of the past. I do not wonder SDL does not want to support it - I would not comfortable if my business depended on a proprietary, third-party software...
As you said yourself, XML is the way of the future and MS workflow is not particularly well suited for that (it is possible, but it just adds another layer of error-prone conversion).
As for the editors, it happens that the topic was discussed lately at DonationCoder:
Still, if you're using right tools (i.e. CATs), the need to manually edit XML files should be minimal.
To report site rules violations or get help, contact a site moderator:
You can also contact site staff by submitting a support request »