Other synonyms for you to chose one that rhymes best: God-fearing, Holy Joe, Jesus freak, born again, clerical, devoted, devout, divine, ecclesiastical, godly, goody two-shoes, goody-goody, got religion, hallowed, holy, knee bender, orthodox, prayerful, priestlike, priestly, religious, reverent, righteous, sacred, saintly, sanctimonious, spiritual...
From the ref site:
"Her boyfriend likes to stalk her, he claims that she was a 'goody too-shoos' and declined the boobie implants..."
Local time: 17:53
Native speaker of: Spanish, English
PRO pts in pair: 193