Aug 7, 2004 09:29
19 yrs ago
Chinese term

中心值 5 標準差 1

Chinese to English Other Mathematics & Statistics
從常態分佈的中心值5標準差1隨機取出可能為1到9之間的整數來設定個體的分支度權重

Discussion

Roddy Stegemann Aug 8, 2004:
"??18:26 ????" should have read "ͬ��18:26��ەr�g".
Roddy Stegemann Aug 8, 2004:
??18:26 ???? - The last sentence should have read: "This indicates a strong upward bias."
Wenjer Leuschel (X) Aug 8, 2004:
������Щ����������࣬��ĩ���������Ϊͳ��ѧ��������Խ
Roddy Stegemann Aug 8, 2004:
18:10 ��ەr�g - Currently the mean score is 4+3 and the median score is 4+2.5. This indicated a strong upward bias.
Non-ProZ.com Aug 8, 2004:
Correction: "I want to hear all the comments..."
Non-ProZ.com Aug 8, 2004:
@Yueyin Hehehe... I want to hear what all the comments before I say anything. I posted this question because I found it weird too.... You're right, I'm always doing those ����! :p
ysun Aug 8, 2004:
weiwei, you are a ����ר�� and a trouble-maker! Are you translating something in �˫�������:)
Edward LIU Aug 8, 2004:
�Ҷ�jyuan_us�Ŀ������ҹ�ͬ�����ڵ���ѧ���֪����λ���ƽ��ֵ����д��ƪ������ѧˮƽ�϶�Ҫ����ѧ�Ҫ�ߣ��ô��ֲ������򵥵����⣿
ysun Aug 8, 2004:
I would appreciate it very much if anyone who has taken statistics will translate the whole sentence into English so that we would be able to get a whole picture. ����ߴͽ̣� Thank you very much in advance!
Edward LIU Aug 8, 2004:
In a normal distribution, the mean, median, and mode are all the same value. There is no point arguing over whether the author should have used a proper word. He has the freedom to choose any term as long as his message is correctly carried over.
Wenjer Leuschel (X) Aug 8, 2004:
����ͳ��ѧ�Ķ������Ҳ���� Hamo ˵���е������⻹�ǡ�����ֵ���Ǹ��ʲ�Ӧ���Ǹ��÷���������ߵ���˼���� median��
jyuan_us Aug 7, 2004:
���"����ֵ"�ܿ������ij���ֶ� mean �����롣
jyuan_us Aug 7, 2004:
Hamo and Terry �������⿴����ͬ���Ҿ���Ӧ������ǵġ��������ֻҪ�Ϲ���ѧ���˾Ͷ���ͳ��ѧ����MEAN, MEDIAN, SD��Щ������һ��ͳ�ƿξ�Ҫ���ģ���ǵ�˵��Ӧ��û�����й��ĺܶ�רҵ�Dz���ͳ��ѧ�εġ��漰ͳ�Ʒ�������֣�����ôʲ���������ġ����"����ֵ"�ܿ���
jyuan_us Aug 7, 2004:
You know what? Hamo has made some sense here. �˜ʲ�ȷʵ����λ�ûʲô��������ԭ��is very unusual.
jyuan_us Aug 7, 2004:
����10���.
jyuan_us Aug 7, 2004:
���Ľ���λ��ȽϿ�ѧ�����Ǹ����1ǰ��0������λ�Ϊ4.5.

Proposed translations

+8
19 mins
Chinese term (edited): ����ֵ 5 �˜ʲ� 1
Selected

median of 5 and standard deviation of 1

median of 5 and standard deviation of 1

--------------------------------------------------
Note added at 33 mins (2004-08-07 10:02:49 GMT)
--------------------------------------------------

An integer ranging from 1 to 9 is randomly selected from a normal distribution with a median of 5 and a standard deviation of 1 to determine individual branch weighting.
Peer comment(s):

agree Wenjer Leuschel (X) : Yes, the median from 1 to 9 is 5. Quantities can have a mean, but not numbers.
52 mins
Thanks, Wenjer.
agree HymnLau
2 hrs
Thanks, Hymn.
agree Beth Dennison
2 hrs
Thanks, Beth.
agree zhongren (X)
3 hrs
Thanks, Zhongren.
agree Chinoise
3 hrs
Thanks.
agree Ray Luo
5 hrs
Thanks, Ray.
agree jyuan_us : yes, median=5
6 hrs
agree ysun : Median = 中值;mean = 平均值。For details, see http://www.ltcconline.net/greenl/courses/201/descstat/mean.h...
9 hrs
Something went wrong...
4 KudoZ points awarded for this answer. Comment: "THANKS!! It was a very informative discussion. I will check this out with the client...."
+1
5 hrs
Chinese term (edited): ����ֵ 5 �˜ʲ� 1

central value 5 and standard deviattion 1.

中心值 5 標準差 1:
central value 5 and standard deviattion 1 or:
central value 5 and root-mean-square deviattion 1.
Peer comment(s):

agree Chinoise
24 mins
Thanks.
Something went wrong...
+2
6 hrs
Chinese term (edited): ����ֵ 5 �˜ʲ� 1

supporting Xianjun's suggestion

Median
The median is the value halfway through the ordered data set, below and above which there lies an equal number of data values.
http://www.cas.lancs.ac.uk/glossary_v1.1/presdata.html#med

Standard Deviation
Standard deviation is a measure of the spread or dispersion of a set of data.
*********************
It is calculated by taking the square root of the variance and is symbolised by s.d, or s. That is:
         __   __
        √V(X) = √σ^2 = s
The more widely the values are spread out, the larger the standard deviation. For example, say we have two separate lists of exam results from a class of 30 students; one ranges from 31% to 98%, the other from 82% to 93%, then the standard deviation would be larger for the results of the first exam.
http://www.cas.lancs.ac.uk/glossary_v1.1/presdata.html#stand...

Sample Mean
The sample mean is an estimator available for estimating the population mean . It is a measure of location, commonly called the average, often symbolised -x.
*********************
Example
Lets say our data set is: 5 3 54 93 83 22 17 19.
The sample mean is calculated by taking the sum of all the data values and dividing by the total number of data values:

          5+3+54+93+83+22+17+19
      -x = ------------------------- = 37
               8
Its value depends equally on all of the data which may include outliers. It may not appear representative of the central region for skewed data sets.
It is especially useful as being representative of the whole sample for use in subsequent calculations.
http://www.cas.lancs.ac.uk/glossary_v1.1/presdata.html#sampm...

2. Mean and standard deviation
The median is known as a measure of location; that is, it tells us where the data are. As stated in , we do not need to know all the exact values to calculate the median; if we made the smallest value even smaller or the largest value even larger, it would not change the value of the median. Thus the median does not use all the information in the data and so it can be shown to be less efficient than the mean or average, which does use all values of the data. To calculate the mean we add up the observed values and divide by the number of them.The total of the values obtained in Table 1.1 was 22.5μmol/24hr, which was divided by their number, 15, to give a mean of 1.5μmol/24hr. This familiar process is conveniently expressed by the following symbols:

         (Σx)
      -x = ------
          n  
-x(pronounced "x bar") signifies the mean; x is each of the values of urinary lead; n is the number of these values; and , the Greek capital sigma (our "S") denotes "sum of". A major disadvantage of the mean is that it is sensitive to outlying points. For example, replacing 2.2 by 22 in Table 1.1 increases the mean to 2.82μmol/24hr, whereas the median will be unchanged.
http://bmj.bmjjournals.com/collections/statsbk/2.shtml

Judging with the explanations of the above links, I have to say that "median" is meant in your case, not "mean," because (Σ1..9)/9 doesn't equal to 5. The number 5 is obviously the "median," not the "mean."


--------------------------------------------------
Note added at 7 hrs 12 mins (2004-08-07 16:42:01 GMT)
--------------------------------------------------

Ooops, (Σ1..9)/9 = (1+9)/2 =5 !
It is the mean and the median!

--------------------------------------------------
Note added at 7 hrs 13 mins (2004-08-07 16:42:46 GMT)
--------------------------------------------------

I mean in this special case.

--------------------------------------------------
Note added at 7 hrs 38 mins (2004-08-07 17:08:36 GMT)
--------------------------------------------------

The reason why the median equals to the mean is that the SD equals to one.
Should the SD differ from one, the median would differ from the mean.
Peer comment(s):

agree Chinoise
2 hrs
Hm, Betty. I am wondering how could you vote for so many different assertions. Actually, I am pondering all the time whether it could mean the mean and not the median in this case. Anyway, we'll have a right answer at the end.
agree ysun
2 hrs
Thank you, Yueyin. But now, I am not so sure about this one.
Something went wrong...
+4
49 mins
Chinese term (edited): ����ֵ 5 �˜ʲ� 1

Mean or median? They are not the same.

Although the word median does appear to be the correct translation of the word 中心, it is unusual for the median and standard deviation to be mentioned together with no mention of the mean. This is because the standard deviation cannot be calculated without the mean and the mean can be determined independently of both the mean and standard deviation.

I suggest you check with the author, or verify within the text that it is indeed the median that is meant.



--------------------------------------------------
Note added at 2 hrs 50 mins (2004-08-07 12:20:41 GMT)
--------------------------------------------------

The passage \"Although the word median does appear to be the correct translation of the word 中心, it is unusual for the median and standard deviation to be mentioned together with no mention of the mean. This is because the standard deviation cannot be calculated without the mean and the mean can be determined independently of both the mean and standard deviation\" should have read:

\"Although the word median does appear to be the correct translation of the word 中心, it is unusual for the median and standard deviation to be mentioned together with no mention of the mean. This is because the standard deviation cannot be calculated without the mean and the median can be determined independently of both the mean and standard deviation.\"

My apologies to HymnLau, if this created confusion for him.


--------------------------------------------------
Note added at 2 hrs 58 mins (2004-08-07 12:28:15 GMT)
--------------------------------------------------

Finally, a normal distribution is defined by two parameters: the mean and standard deviation. Without knowledge of these there can be no normal distribution. This is further evidence to warrant consultation with the author or a sound understanding of the text.

Please do not translate something that you do not understand, even if it makes grammatical sense.

--------------------------------------------------
Note added at 12 hrs 20 mins (2004-08-07 21:49:59 GMT)
--------------------------------------------------

Wenjer Leuschel: After having read your further note I offer the following comment. You have done exactly what I have suggested the translator do, verify within the text whether the median is truly what the author meant to say. So, why do you write disagree.

Finally, although the values of the mean and median can be the same in special cases, by definition they are very different statistics measuring two very different phenomena.



--------------------------------------------------
Note added at 18 hrs 19 mins (2004-08-08 03:49:37 GMT)
--------------------------------------------------

With regard to Yan Li\'s entry I would avoid the term root-mean-square, as the standard deviation is a special use of the root-mean-square. Whereas the root-mean-square is a geometric measure of central tendency, the standard deviation is an average measure of dispersion.

According to the following link physical scientists sometimes confound the two terms, but such confusion would probably not be well received by statisticians. Certainly, I have never seen these terms confounded in economics.

http://mathworld.wolfram.com/Root-Mean-Square.html

By the way, <mathworld.wolfram.com> appears to be an excellent online source for many questions related to mathematics. It could even help Yan Li with his spelling of mathematical terms!
Peer comment(s):

neutral HymnLau : In Statistics, median stands for 中心值 & mean normally refer to "average"
1 hr
So why do you register as neutral, instead of agree? Whether you put ֵ or not is immaterial. Please reread my entry and make sure that you understand it.
agree Terry Thatcher Waltz, Ph.D. : I believe it should be "mean" when talking about standard deviations; "median" doesn't have anything to do with SD generally speaking
2 hrs
Thank you for your kind affirmation.
agree Chinoise
3 hrs
neutral Wenjer Leuschel (X) : Please read my posting supporting Xianjun's view.// Add: I turn to neutral, because the mean and the median are different and I am not sure about them in this case.
6 hrs
I read your comment before I offered mine. It did not make any more sense then, than it does now. The mean is derived from the relative importance of numbers within a distribution and the median from their relative position within.
agree jyuan_us : Hamo, it makes sense. 標準差确实与中位数没什么关联,这段原文is very unusual.Hamo and Terry 两个老外看法相同,我觉得应该信他们的。在美国,只要上过大学的人就懂点统计学,而MEAN, MEDIAN, SD这些玩意儿第一堂统计课就要讲的,他们的说法应该没错。而中国的很多专业是
9 hrs
Yes, statistics are fundamental to US graduate training in both economics and linguistics, and a good understanding of these basic terms is commonplace among students within these disciplines. Your support is well received. 多謝!
agree Andreas Yan : Thanks for your comment,Hamo.
18 hrs
My pleasure. I hope it was useful!
Something went wrong...
Term search
  • All of ProZ.com
  • Term search
  • Jobs
  • Forums
  • Multiple search