Glossary entry (derived from question below)
Spanish term or phrase:
planteo de competencia negativa
English translation:
issue raised of a negative jurisdictional conflict
Added to glossary by
Adrian MM.
Aug 3, 2021 08:01
3 yrs ago
23 viewers *
Spanish term
planteo de competencia negativa
Spanish to English
Law/Patents
Law (general)
A defence lawyer speaking in court in Argentina: "El señor XXX, como juez de instrucción, tuvo un planteo de competencia negativa con la Justicia Federal."
Is "competencia negativa" the same as negative jurisdiction? Could this be described as a motion for negative jurisdiction? The judge does not believe that this is his jurisdiction/competence and asks for this to be changed.
Thanks in advance.
Is "competencia negativa" the same as negative jurisdiction? Could this be described as a motion for negative jurisdiction? The judge does not believe that this is his jurisdiction/competence and asks for this to be changed.
Thanks in advance.
Proposed translations
(English)
3 | issue raised of a negative jurisdictional conflict | Adrian MM. |
3 | proposal to raise a dispute | Lisa Rosengard |
Change log
Aug 4, 2021 19:51: Adrian MM. Created KOG entry
Proposed translations
3 hrs
Selected
issue raised of a negative jurisdictional conflict
... triggering a transfer of venue motion.....
tener un planteo: possibly > the judge ran into or faced - unclear to me who entered the plea or motion - into a negative jurisdictional conflict.
'Los conflictos negativos de competencia pueden ser planteados por una persona física o jurídica y por el Gobierno frente al órgano ejecutivo de una Comunidad Autónoma.'
plantear caso federal: Arg. raise a federal question, West.
juez de instrucción : query an examining justice in a criminal case or a civil case where jurisdction is accepted or *declined*.
'For their part, negative conflicts of jurisdiction happen when two or more MS refuse to take on a certain case on the grounds of their lack of authority over it.'
tener un planteo: possibly > the judge ran into or faced - unclear to me who entered the plea or motion - into a negative jurisdictional conflict.
'Los conflictos negativos de competencia pueden ser planteados por una persona física o jurídica y por el Gobierno frente al órgano ejecutivo de una Comunidad Autónoma.'
plantear caso federal: Arg. raise a federal question, West.
juez de instrucción : query an examining justice in a criminal case or a civil case where jurisdction is accepted or *declined*.
'For their part, negative conflicts of jurisdiction happen when two or more MS refuse to take on a certain case on the grounds of their lack of authority over it.'
Example sentence:
Artículo 47 En el caso de competencia negativa entre la jurisdicción ordinaria y otra privilegiada, la ordinaria empezará o continuará la causa.
IATE: organisation of the legal system [LAW] COM en negative conflict of jurisdiction COM es conflicto negativo COM
4 KudoZ points awarded for this answer.
Comment: "Thanks, Adrian."
18 hrs
proposal to raise a dispute
When an issue of a proposal or an approach to raise a dispute between judiciary decision-making authorities occurs, the Supreme Court shall make a decision. In the event of a dispute, an ordinary (common law) jurisdiction begins or continues with the cause.
SP: "En el evento de un propósito para plantear una disputa o un litigio entre una decisión judicial de una autoridad ordinaria y otra autoridad superior, la Corte Suprema toma una decisión. En el caso de una disputa o un litigio, una jurisdicción ordinaria empieza o continúa con la causa."
SP: "En el evento de un propósito para plantear una disputa o un litigio entre una decisión judicial de una autoridad ordinaria y otra autoridad superior, la Corte Suprema toma una decisión. En el caso de una disputa o un litigio, una jurisdicción ordinaria empieza o continúa con la causa."
Something went wrong...