Glossary entry

French term or phrase:

problématique

English translation:

problematic

Added to glossary by Richard Robinson
Nov 26, 2008 10:00
15 yrs ago
8 viewers *
French term

problématique

French to English Social Sciences Education / Pedagogy academic writing
...comment passer de la thématique à un questionnement de recherche puis à une problématique...

This sentence occurs in a guide for tutors supervising Masters theses. It seems to me to imply a gradual move from the general to the specific, which would imply that "problématique" is "hypothesis" - except that "hypothèse" is used elsewhere in the same guide.

OR: problematique could be "research question" (the client actually recommended this) - but then the sentence becomes "how to move from the proposal to the research question, and subsequently to the research question" - that would be daft. I have the same misgivings about "research area" - an "area" is no more specific than a "question" (less so, if anything).

[Note: thématique here refers to the fiche thématique, the (formal) research proposal.]

One thing I have clarified is that Masters theses do not have a "thesis statement", so that's not the answer. Any thoughts (dare I say, answers?) gratefully received.

Proposed translations

+3
1 hr
Selected

problematic

Ugly as it is, 'research problematic' is in frequent usage:

Guide to writing a research proposal



A formal proposal is required for admission to a research degree. It is one means by which university committees assess and approve your research candidature.

The process of developing the proposal can be a valuable exercise, one which can help you determine your focus, clarify what is involved in your research project and plan its development. A developed proposal is an important way in which you can demonstrate your understanding of research and communicate your ‘research thinking’ to others.

These guidelines are provided to help you draw out your ideas. They state the requirements of a sound proposal.

1 Topic and problematic

The research topic formulates a problem that is worthy of research. The topic should:

be stated clearly and succinctly in one or two sentences.
be determined after consultation with potential supervisors.
The topic is usually framed as a ‘problem’ or question in need of an answer. The topic statement will invite your reader to ask why it is significant and ‘worth doing’. A good research proposal identifies in the research topic a ‘problematic’ to be investigated. Needless to say, your statement of this will result from discussion of your area of interest with potential supervisors, mentors and others.

http://www.uts.edu.au/fac/edu/research/degrees/guide.html

--------------------------------------------------
Note added at 2 hrs (2008-11-26 12:02:02 GMT)
--------------------------------------------------

I should also have included this paragraph from the above link:

Framing the question is not always easy, and you need to ask yourself whether your proposed ‘problem’ or ‘research question’ is really the question to be asked and answered. The framing of the problematic is crucial in setting up the research, though it is a common for researchers to revise and reformulate this as the research progresses."

Other examples:

"Research problematic



Instructional intervention : a research object under construction

The research problematic of the Crie and of the Canada Research Chair on Instructional Intervention is in direct relation with the Strategic Plan for Development in Research and Teaching of the University of Sherbrooke (2001), with the orientations of the Faculty of Education (1996) with the problematic of the doctorate in education (Ph.D.), centred on interrelations between research, teacher education and professional practices, and with the orientations of the Centre for Interuniversity Research in Teacher Education and the Teaching Profession (Crifpe) that the Crie is part of.



The research problematic deals with a fundamental question in education. Indeed, it is centred on instructional intervention in teaching and in professional pre-service and continuing education in teaching, and on the development of behaviours connected to it, according to an interdisciplinary approach or perspective. In this sense, the populations concerned by the works conducted by the CRIE are, on the one hand, practising teachers and all actors in the school milieu (pedagogical consultants, school principals, etc.) in their function of intervener with these teachers and, on the other hand, future teachers and all actors (university professors, sessional lecturers, practice teaching supervisors, associate teachers, etc.) acting in their capacity of intervener in their teacher education process."

http://www.crie.ca/CRIE/CRIE_prob_anglais.htm

http://books.google.co.uk/books?id=RKXILlvkd04C&pg=PA45&lpg=...


At the time of working up of my own PhD proposal, I remember discussion taking place which used the word 'problematize': 'one needs to problematize this area of one's research/research focus.'


--------------------------------------------------
Note added at 2 days2 hrs (2008-11-28 12:57:23 GMT) Post-grading
--------------------------------------------------

That's great - a better outcome even than 4 points, for which many thanks!
Note from asker:
Dear Helen, I want to thank you for your exhaustive reply to my question about problématique. The fact I was able to cite you and the references you gave as sources has helped earned me credibility from the client and the promise of more work. Thank you! Richard
Peer comment(s):

agree liz askew
42 mins
Thank you, liz
agree sueaberwoman : First source convincing - the explanation IMO corresponds to the term's use in French. The second sounds as if written by a knowledgeable French speaker (so less convincing). Also: www.history.fas.nyu.edu/docs/IO/7684/G571772Walkowitz.pdf
7 hrs
Thanks, sueaberwoman - I did also give a third source; thanks for yours.
agree Harald Moelzer (medical-translator) : with sue
19 hrs
Thank you, Harald
Something went wrong...
4 KudoZ points awarded for this answer. Comment: "Thank you Helen. Although the other answers certainly have validity, I've selected this one because of the number of citations that support it. And also because (as a native speaker) you admit that the word is ugly, which is why I was avoiding it in the first place! "
+1
3 mins

research focus

perhaps?
Peer comment(s):

agree Katy Harris
22 mins
Something went wrong...
19 mins

hypothesis

-
Something went wrong...
3 hrs

research issues covered

have this for use in other contexts but am just throwing it in - here 'problématique' seems to be what the previous insights indicate should be the focus of the research
Something went wrong...
Term search
  • All of ProZ.com
  • Term search
  • Jobs
  • Forums
  • Multiple search