Jun 15, 2019 13:54
5 yrs ago
11 viewers *
German term

Selbst ist der Mensch

German to English Bus/Financial Idioms / Maxims / Sayings Business negotiations
Hi,
Hoping someone can help with this one. I don't have a lot of context for the term itself - it's a motto certain people live their lives by. It goes on to say these are people who are tough negotiators. Winning is the most important thing to them. I found something in French that suggests it means something along the lines of "I can do this better than anyone". Or is it maybe "Each man for himself"? of "I come first"? I'd be grateful if anyone is familiar with this phrase.
Change log

Jun 15, 2019 15:09: Steffen Walter changed "Field" from "Other" to "Bus/Financial"

Discussion

Stuart and Aida Nelson Jun 17, 2019:
Ramey - self-sufficiency not selfish Yes, I agree, there is a bit of boasting in 'blow your own trumpet' (Adrian's answer), which in terms of marketing is also good for a business but 'being full of yourself' can also mean self-sufficient as this article nicely explains:

How Being Full of Yourself Isn't Selfish

When I fill myself up, I have little need for others to do it for me and paradoxically, I welcome the genuine, from the heart gifts that life offers to me. When I see myself as that full to overflowing glass, I am certain that I can be a greater force for good and quench, not only my own thirst, but that of a parched world.
https://www.huffpost.com/entry/how-being-full-of-yoursel_b_6...
Ramey Rieger (X) Jun 17, 2019:
Hi Aida But it doesn't entail bravado or egotism. It's self-contained, not boasting.
Stuart and Aida Nelson Jun 17, 2019:
entails self sufficiency I fully agree with Ramey and Anne. That's why I also agreed with Adrian's: 'being full of yourself'. In this context 'selbst ist der Mensch' should reflect toughness, self-sufficiency, Cheers, Aida
Ramey Rieger (X) Jun 17, 2019:
My issue with 'do it yourself' is its sheer overuse. It immediately brings to mind putting up IKEA shelves. Selbst ist die Frau/der Mann also entails emotional stability or self sufficiency. A certain earthiness.
Wendy Streitparth Jun 16, 2019:
I'd go with one of Bernard's options.
Anne Schulz Jun 15, 2019:
I agree with the colleagues that "Selbst ist der Mensch" is a modification of "Selbst ist der Mann" (or, "Selbst ist die Frau") – 'Do it yourself' in the sense of 'You can do it!'<br />A web search on "Selbst ist der Mensch" mainly returns websites dealing with either inclusion of the disabled or self-actualisation seminars for shy people. 'Do it yourself' in the sense of 'You can do it', again. <br />"People who are tough negotiators" and "Winning is the most important thing to them" is quite different from that. You might therefore look for a saying which reflects "tough" and "winning", rather than sticking to the (possibly inappropriate) German saying of "Selbst ist der Mensch".
Stuart and Aida Nelson Jun 15, 2019:
Selbst ist der Mensch I think this explains it very well :)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-EbN3-LYHBg
Björn Vrooman Jun 15, 2019:
Hello Kathy, hello Phil I don't see much of an issue with Kim's version. Reminded me of "If you want something done right, do it yourself."

[...which, ofc, is just a slightly altered version of what you wrote in your post below.]

And here's a good example in your context:
http://www.how-to-negotiate.com/negotiating-your-bottom-line...

Best
Kathy Freeman (asker) Jun 15, 2019:
I think something like "If you want a job done well, do it yourself" - based on Kim's research
Kathy Freeman (asker) Jun 15, 2019:
I don't have much more context sorry.
philgoddard Jun 15, 2019:
Could we have the German context, please.

Proposed translations

+5
23 mins
Selected

do it yourself

According to these forum comments, it's a politically correct version of selbst ist der Mann.
Es geht darum, dass man etwas selbst erledigen muss, wenn einem keiner hilft.
Selbst ist der Mann (, wenn er kann)! ;)
Das ist übrigens auch die traditionelle Übersetzung von Do it yourself.

Nur als Ergänzung: "Selbst ist der Mann" ist eine feste Redewendung. "Selbst ist der Mensch" scheint eine "politisch korrekte" Variante zu sein. Ich habe sie noch nicht gehört.
https://forum.wordreference.com/threads/selbst-ist-der-mensc...
Peer comment(s):

agree writeaway : nice research Kim
18 mins
neutral philgoddard : I agree about your research, but I'm not sure your suggested translation works.
33 mins
agree Björn Vrooman : I think this could work in Kathy's context. I should add, I guess, that in addition to your Selbst ist der Mann, Selbst ist die Frau has been around for a long time. So maybe this isn't really PC, but simply shorter than saying Mann/Frau =)
1 hr
agree Adrian MM. : Langenscheidt: 'there's nothing like doing things by yourself'.
4 hrs
agree Eleanore Strauss : concise and spot-on transcreation
11 hrs
agree José Patrício : to do it yourself - https://www.phrasen.com/uebersetze,to-do-it-yourself,68078,e...
2 days 6 hrs
Something went wrong...
4 KudoZ points awarded for this answer. Comment: "Thanks Kim. All great suggestions but I am giving Kim the points for a speedy clarification and great research. Thanks everyone. "
1 hr

Learn from others but only rely on yourself

Supposing the person is intelligent...
Do it yourself sounds to me like a hands-on thing, like fixing the leaking faucet etc.
Something went wrong...
2 hrs

Forge your own path

If the source text had said "Selbst ist der Mann", this would have conjured up images of men with great DIY home repair skills.

But what we have here is "Selbst ist der Mensch" which, as a motto, I would typically associate with "Selbstbestimmung."
Something went wrong...
4 hrs

Scratch your own itch

...may work.

The Italian version is the best, though: "Chi fa da se, fa per tre."
Peer comment(s):

neutral Stuart and Aida Nelson : I also like 'scratch your own itch' but I am not sure if it fits the context here and the Italian sounds very nice, Cheers, Aida :)
4 hrs
Thanks, Aida!
Something went wrong...
+1
5 hrs

(BrE) There's no harm being full of yourself (and blowing your own trumpet)

A somewaht paradoxical turn of phrase to use on this website.

My own experience of tough (leasing agreement etc.) negotiators would rather suggest: 'try pretending to be a human being'.
Example sentence:

If you say to someone 'you're full of yourself', you disapprove of them because they appear very pleased with themselves, thinking that they are very clever.

Peer comment(s):

agree Stuart and Aida Nelson : I like it, Being Full of Yourself! The meaning here is to be tough.
3 hrs
Thanks and gracias! The meaning of self still needs to be reflected,
neutral Michael Martin, MA : Is that what it means in the UK? Here, this just means you have a big head/Being full of yourself often implies that rather than being a tough negotiator that person may be too stupid to notice he's been outsmarted by his counterpart.
1 day 15 hrs
It does in the UK, too. 'Tough negotiators', as colo(u)red by my own subjective experience and City of London anecdotes - alluded to - of (rude) lawyers/ attorneys (re-) negotiating leases etc, strike me as code or euphemistic for a big-shot label.
Something went wrong...
+2
15 hrs

Rely on yourself

or:

trust yourself
rely on yourself

see: https://medium.com/darius-foroux/self-reliance-is-the-secret...


This might be more than a variation of the "Selbst ist der Mann," judging from asker's comments. Goes more in the direction of rely on yourself, no one else ....

...I trust in myself first (before I trust in anyone else)
Trust in yourself only
(I/you) don't need anybody else
Trust no one (but yourself)

Nobody tells me how to live my life -
I'm my own man/woman/person

see:
https://dictionary.cambridge.org/us/dictionary/english/be-yo...

would go with these if it is a motto for living one's life.
Peer comment(s):

agree Wendy Streitparth : 'Be your own person' sounds good to me
1 hr
Thank you Wendy!
agree Anne Schulz
2 hrs
Thank you Anne!
Something went wrong...
1 day 16 hrs

have both feet firmly on the ground

For what it's worth. That's I get for going off for the weekend.
Something went wrong...
Term search
  • All of ProZ.com
  • Term search
  • Jobs
  • Forums
  • Multiple search