Glossary entry

English term or phrase:

Contempt of Court

Spanish translation:

contumacia/rebeldía; desacato al tribunal

Added to glossary by Manuel Cedeño Berrueta
Dec 14, 2002 17:42
21 yrs ago
83 viewers *
English term

Contempt of Court

English to Spanish Law/Patents
Este término aparece en un Weekly Law Report para calificar el comportamiento de una persona que no ha obedecido una sentencia.
Necesito ayuda, ya que los dos sistemas jurídicos son muy diferentes.

El derecho anglosajón considera "civil contempt" la actuación que aquí detallo y "criminal contempt" la falta de comparecencia en un juicio o los insultos.
Los diccionarios jurídicos me ofrecen la equivalencia "desacto al tribunal" y "cuasi-contumacia".
Sin embargo, consulté el diccionario de la Real Academia y "Contumacia" es la falta de comparecencia y el derecho español entiende como "desacato" los insultos o mal comportamiento en un juicio.
Mi pregunta es ¿debo mantener la equivalencia "Desacato al tribunal" cuando estamos hablando de un delito de desobediencia?
Muchísimas gracias por vuestra ayuda.

Proposed translations

1 hr
Selected

Some definitions that may help you decide

Some definitions that may help you decide between:
desacato, rebeldía, contumacia.

En Venezuela se usa más “contumacia”.
Kind regards,
Manuel
******

CONTEMPT OF COURT - Any willful disobedience to, or disregard of, a court order or any misconduct in the presence of a court; action that interferes with a judge's ability to administer justice or that insults the dignity of the court; punishable by fine or imprisonment or both. There are both civil and criminal contempts; the distinction is often unclear.

Contempt Of Court -- Civil Or Criminal

A judge who feels someone is improperly challenging or ignoring the court's authority has the power to declare the defiant person (called the contemnor) in contempt of court. There are two types of contempt - criminal and civil. Criminal contempt occurs when the contemnor actually interferes with the ability of the court to function properly - for example, by yelling at the judge. This is also called direct contempt because it occurs directly in front of the judge. A criminal contemnor may be fined, jailed or both as punishment for his act.


Civil contempt occurs when the contemnor willfully disobeys a court order. This is also called indirect contempt because it occurs outside the judge's immediate realm and evidence must be presented to the judge to prove the contempt. A civil contemnor, too, may be fined, jailed or both. The fine or jailing is meant to coerce the contemnor into obeying the court, not to punish him, and the contemnor will be released from jail just as soon as he complies with the court order. In family law, civil contempt is one way a court enforces alimony, child support, custody and visitation orders which have been violated.


However, many courts have realized that, at least regarding various procedural matters such as appointment of counsel, the distinction between civil and criminal contempt is often blurred and uncertain.

A Willful Disregard Or Disobedience Of A Public Authority.

By the Constitution of the United States, each house of congress may determine the rules of its proceeding's, punish its members for disorderly behaviour and, with the concurrence of two-thirds, expel a member. The same provision is substantially contained in the constitutions of the several states.

The power to make rules carries that of enforcing them, and to attach persons who violate them and punish them for contempts. This power of punishing for contempts is confined to punishment during the session of the legislature and cannot extend beyond it, and it seems this power cannot be exerted beyond imprisonment.

Courts of justice have an inherent power to punish all persons for contempt of their rules and orders, for disobedience of their process, and for disturbing them in their proceedings.

In some states, as in Pennsylvania, the power to punish for contempts is restricted to offences committed by the officers of the court, or in its presence, or in disobedience of its mandates, orders, or rules; but no one is guilty of a contempt for any publication made or act done out of court which is not in violation of such lawful rules or orders, or disobedience of its process. Similar provisions, limiting the power of the courts of the United States to punish for contempts, are incorporated in 28 U.S.C.

When a person is in prison for a contempt, it has been decided in New York that he cannot be discharged by another judge when brought before him on a habeas corpus; and it belongs exclusively to the court offended to judge of contempts and what amounts to them; and no other court or judge can, or ought to undertake in a collateral way, to question or review an adjudication of a contempt made by another competent jurisdiction.

This way be considered as the established doctrine equally in England as in this country.
--b--

http://www.lectlaw.com/def.htm

There's related stuff in other Library areas, so explore.



DESACATO.
Cometen delito de desacato los que hallándose un ministro o una autoridad en el ejercicio de sus funciones o con ocasión de ellas, los calumniaren, injuriaren, insultaren o amenazaren de hecho o de palabra, en su presencia o por escrito que les dirijan DESAFORAR. Quebrantar los fueros y privilegios que corresponden a una persona.

http://www.lexconsultor.com/diccionario.php

********

contumacia.
(Del lat. contumacĭa).
1. f. Tenacidad y dureza en mantener un error.
2. f. Der. rebeldía (ǁ falta de comparecencia en un juicio).


Real Academia Española © Todos los derechos reservados
rebeldía.

1. f. Cualidad de rebelde.
2. f. Acción propia del rebelde.
3. f. Der. Estado procesal de quien, siendo parte en un juicio, no acude al llamamiento que formalmente le hace el juez o deja incumplidas las intimaciones de este.
en ~.
1. loc. adv. Der. En situación jurídica de rebelde.

Real Academia Española © Todos los derechos reservados
http://www.rae.es/
Something went wrong...
4 KudoZ points awarded for this answer. Comment: "Gracias por ofrecerme tantas referencias. Me han ayudado muchísimo. De todos modos, al leer la información que aportas de las fuentes en español sigo pensando que, en el caso que me ocupa, si me atengo al significado que aparece en la R.A.E., estoy ante un caso de desobediencia al tribunal y no ante un desacato."
+9
11 mins

desacato al tribunal

.

--------------------------------------------------
Note added at 2002-12-14 17:54:50 (GMT)
--------------------------------------------------

Also:
Contumacia

--------------------------------------------------
Note added at 2002-12-14 17:55:44 (GMT)
--------------------------------------------------

La obstrucción del régimen de visitas establecido en las sentencias constituye desacato al tribunal, pero el poder judicial cierra los ojos ante esa infracción y, en cambio, encarcela a un buen padre por el delito de tratar de ver a sus hijas.

http://www.adiospapa.org/mark.htm

--------------------------------------------------
Note added at 2002-12-14 17:56:43 (GMT)
--------------------------------------------------

Luego de evaluar la situación el juez puede ordenar una citación al testigo la cual se unirá una copia de la certificación, ordenando al testigo a que comparezca y declare en el proceso criminal pendiente, en el lugar y sitio indicado. Si el testigo no comparece, sin justa causa, puede ser castigado por desacato al Tribunal.

http://www.tribunalpr.org/testigos.html

--------------------------------------------------
Note added at 2002-12-14 17:58:57 (GMT)
--------------------------------------------------

you can also find it in the glossaries:

http://www.proz.com/?sp=h&id=142659&keyword=Contempt
Peer comment(s):

agree Andrea Ali : exacto
22 mins
agree AlwaysMoving : Esa es la frase! perfecto
58 mins
agree Egmont
1 hr
agree Teresita Garcia Ruy Sanchez
2 hrs
agree José Antonio V.
3 hrs
agree Antonio Villarreal Ulloa
5 hrs
agree EDLING (X)
14 hrs
agree John Bozell
1 day 31 mins
agree Jennifer Brinckmann
2 days 2 hrs
Something went wrong...
+3
30 mins

contumacia, desacato, rebeldía

Habría que tener el contexto para matizar el término en ese contexto.
Peer comment(s):

agree Manuel Cedeño Berrueta
39 mins
agree Egmont : too!
1 hr
agree María del Carmen Cerda : rebeldía
1 day 4 hrs
Something went wrong...
Term search
  • All of ProZ.com
  • Term search
  • Jobs
  • Forums
  • Multiple search