Jun 27, 2005 05:46
19 yrs ago
20 viewers *
English term

mentally retarded

English Medical Medical (general)
The reviewer of the paper said,
Change log

Jun 27, 2005 07:35: Elizabeth Rudin changed "Field" from "Art/Literary" to "Medical" , "Field (specific)" from "Science (general)" to "Medical (general)"

Discussion

RHELLER Jun 27, 2005:
the important point here is not the definition but the acceptability of usage
RHELLER Jun 27, 2005:
Mitsuko, you MUST give target country because each country has its own preferences.
Ian M-H (X) Jun 27, 2005:
Is the paper *about* learning, cognitive development, emotional development, or is it mainly about something else with references to development being incidental? The more you can tell us, the better people will be able to advise.
Ian M-H (X) Jun 27, 2005:
What is the paper under review about and what kind of journal is it for? As the answers below show, different terms will be appropriate for different audiences in different contexts.

Responses

+5
1 hr
Selected

depends on the context

It depends on the context:

“Mental retardation” or “mentally retarded” are perfectly acceptable terms, widely used by medical professionals in a medical context.
However, ”developmentally delayed” or “mentally disabled” are preferred and recommended in the wider social context, to avoid the connotations of “mental retardation”.
In the UK, developmentally delayed persons are most often described/referred to as children or adults with learning difficulties.
Peer comment(s):

agree Charlesp
2 hrs
Thank you, Charles.
agree Robert Donahue (X) : I can't buy the argument that you use with Rita. Organizations can't just change their names to adapt to the times (taxes, printing costs, etc). Take the NAACP for example. Try calling someone "colored" nowadays in the US and see where that gets you. : )
4 hrs
Thank you, Robert.
agree Angela Dickson (X)
11 hrs
Thank you, Angela.
neutral RHELLER : sorry but mental retardation is no longer considered acceptable in the U.S. (and asker has not specified target country)
12 hrs
More info at http://www.aamr.org/ - the American Association on Mental Retardation. There is even an American Journal on Mental Retardation (AJMR).
agree aira07 : I believe mentally retarded is a medically accepted term, but no longer PC in a wider social context such as comedy
2 days 1 hr
Thank you, aira.
agree Saleh Chowdhury, Ph.D.
5 days
Thank you, Saleh.
Something went wrong...
4 KudoZ points awarded for this answer. Comment: "Thank you very much!"
11 mins

mentally challenged

Another safe way of putting it is:
mentally challenged

As in physically challenged.

--------------------------------------------------
Note added at 16 mins (2005-06-27 06:03:17 GMT)
--------------------------------------------------

From the following link, it appears that there is nothing wrong in using \"mentally retarded\". It seems to be a standard psychiatric term.

-------
The three traditional terms denoting varying degrees of mental deficiency long predate psychiatry. They were originally used in English as simple forms of abuse, and this is still the main usage. Their now obsolete use as psychiatric technical definitions is of purely historical interest. There have been some efforts made among mental health professionals to discourage use of these terms. Note that the term retard or tard is still used as a generic insult, especially among children.

Idiot indicated the greatest degree of mental deficiency, where the mental age is 2 years or less, and the person cannot guard himself against common physical dangers. The term was gradually replaced by the term profound mental retardation.
Imbecile indicated a mental deficiency less extreme than idiocy and not necessarily inherited. It is now usually subdivided into two categories, known as severe mental retardation and moderate mental retardation.
Moron was defined by the American Association for the Study of the Feeble-Minded in 1910, following work by Henry H. Goddard, as the term for an adult with a mental age between eight and twelve; mild mental retardation is now the term for this condition. Alternative definitions of these terms based on IQ were also used.

http://www.answers.com/mentally retarded

----

--------------------------------------------------
Note added at 35 mins (2005-06-27 06:22:24 GMT)
--------------------------------------------------

developmentally delayed and mentally retarded are synonyms according to this site:

Healthopedia.com - Mental Retardation (Developmentally Delayed ...
Mental Retardation. Alternate Names : Developmentally Delayed, Mentally Disabled.
Overview, Causes, & Risk Factors | Symptoms & Signs | Diagnosis & Tests ...
www.healthopedia.com/mental-retardation/

Peer comment(s):

neutral Terence Ajbro : the problem is, though, this can mean anything, whereas the expression "mentally retarded" is a more meaningful designation of a mental condition. Understanding is thus sacrificed in the name of political correctness
4 mins
True. "Mentally retarded" seems to me to be just fine too. Please see added note.
agree Kirill Semenov : http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Political_correctness#Examples
41 mins
Thanks.
neutral Dr Sue Levy (X) : "mentally challenged" will not do in a scientific paper
54 mins
Thanks.
neutral Angela Dickson (X) : agree with Sue
12 hrs
Thanks.
neutral RHELLER : not in my opinon
13 hrs
Thanks.
disagree Paula Vaz-Carreiro : In the UK at least, the word "challenged" associated with disability of any kind is always a kind of joke on political correctness!- as in, a person is not 'short' but 'vertically challenged'.
3 days 4 hrs
Thanks.
Something went wrong...
-3
1 hr

developmentally challanged

(no, not developmentally delayed)
Peer comment(s):

disagree Sven Petersson : Undefined, meaningless political SONK.
9 mins
hej Sven. Thanks for the comment, but that is the term the asker wanted. (What is SONK anyway?)
disagree Angela Dickson (X) : that's not often heard in scientific/medical contexts in my experience - 'delayed' can be an accurate term
10 hrs
disagree
disagree Paula Vaz-Carreiro : In the UK at least, the word "challenged" associated with disability of any kind is always a kind of joke on political correctness!- as in, a person is not 'short' but 'vertically challenged'.
3 days 2 hrs
Something went wrong...
2 hrs

Explanation

Mentally retarded is always used for mentally handicapped children as well as adults and it is normally incurable. But delayed in development such as delayed in cognitive abilities can be removed. using one of them depends on the text. Today psychologist prefer the next term, of course.
Peer comment(s):

neutral RHELLER : sorry fareedeh - mentally retarded is no longer considered acceptable language in the U.S.
11 hrs
Dear Rita: I couldn't see your comment untill now, I wanted to say developmentally disabled or delayed in development is preferd.
Something went wrong...
14 hrs

not for grading

because of the excited responses to my comments - I now have to justify my comments - all because the asker has not properly formulated a question which explains the target audience and target country.
there are nuances - I am aware of it -

Caremark.com
Mental retardation is a developmental disability that first appears in children under the age ... The Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, ...
www.caremark.com/.../5522/.cmd/ad/.pm/-/.c/ 1703/.ce/5535/.p/3711/_s.155/5522?PC_3711_docid=CMS-2-MM000878 - 53k
Peer comment(s):

neutral Mihaela Brooks : Why the DSM terminology I already mentioned is acceptable to you now?// I fully understand 'nuances', I wonder if you understand "neither"..moreover in US metnal retardation is fully accepted./next time do your homework
30 mins
do you not understand the word nuance?I am just as entitled to my opinion as you are -
Something went wrong...
+1
50 mins

mental retardation a.k.a. mental deficiency

DSM IVTR includes mental retardedness as one of the abnormal behaviours

WHAT IS MENTAL RETARDATION?
Definition
The DSM-1V2 defines mental retardation as follows:


Significantly subaverage intellectual functioning-ie, an IQ of approximately 70 or below.

Deficits or impairments in adaptive functioning.

Onset before age 18 years.



mental retardation
n.
Subnormal intellectual development as a result of congenital causes, brain injury, or disease and characterized by any of various cognitive deficiencies, including impaired learning, social, and vocational ability. Also called ****mental deficiency****.
http://www.answers.com/topic/mental-retardation


--------------------------------------------------
Note added at 15 hrs 0 min (2005-06-27 20:47:16 GMT)
--------------------------------------------------

Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders - Fourth Edition (DSM-IV), published by the American Psychiatric Association, Washington D.C., 1994, the main diagnostic reference of Mental Health professionals in the United States of America.
Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders - Fourth Edition (DSM-IV), published by the American Psychiatric Association, Washington D.C., 1994, the main diagnostic reference of Mental Health professionals in the United States of America.
http://www.psychologynet.org/dsm.html
Diagnostic and Statistical Manual
of Mental Disorders (DSM)IV

Fourth Edition
The standard diagnostic tool used by mental health professionals worldwide to promote reliable research, accurate diagnosis, and thus appropriate treatment and patient care. Each psychiatric disorder with its corresponding diagnostic code is accompanied by a set of diagnostic criteria and descriptive details including associated features, prevalence, familial patterns, age-, culture-, and gender-specific features, and differential diagnosis.
http://www.psychiatryonline.com/dsmLibrary.aspx
Peer comment(s):

neutral Charlesp : yes, but in some texts such academic/medical precision is not what is called for.
57 mins
what the text is about?
agree Sven Petersson
1 hr
Thanks Sven
neutral RHELLER : neither;1) neither of the answers on your answer line are acceptable;2) what you posted afterwards is medical terminology- the asker has not stated whether this is general medical terminology for the public or very precise diagnostic terminology
13 hrs
Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders.IV-TR.is a current terminology used in psychology/psychiatry/See..Understanding Abnormal Beh. Sue & all.6th ed.pg.470 West WashingtonUniv./If no context: why psychiatric term is unacceptable to you
neutral Robert Donahue (X) : Mihaela, I won't argue with your definitions here. They're correct. The issue at hand is finding a politically correct term. Mentally retarded is not PC in the US.
18 hrs
Robert, the context is not clear re PC or psychiatric terminology. What makes a well-defined medical term PC? PC in which country?
Something went wrong...
+1
6 hrs

developmentally disabled

This is the term that I would use.

Terminology is very important to people trying to change perceptions. Ward is a national leader of "self-advocacy," a term adopted to reflect the desire of people with a variety of disabilities to have their voices heard in decisions affecting their lives. Self-advocates don't like any labels but prefer "developmentally disabled" over "mentally retarded," which they view as pejorative.
http://www.villagelife.org/news/archives/11-4-97_disabledfig...

--------------------------------------------------
Note added at 18 hrs 32 mins (2005-06-28 00:19:39 GMT)
--------------------------------------------------

Bala, I don\'t present the following stats as proof positive, I merely present them to show you that the term that I\'ve proposed fits just fine. I think that you\'re reading too much into a term which is very commonly used in the US (your personal feelings on the matter notwithstanding).

Results 1 - 10 of about 237,000 for \"mentally challenged\".

Results 1 - 10 of about 605,000 for \"developmentally disabled\".
Peer comment(s):

neutral Balasubramaniam L. : My objection to the term is that "development" is a word with wide ranging connotations. Why add another meaning to it. Also "disabled" suggests the person is out of action for good. Which isn't the case. They do lead a meaningful life in their own way.
2 hrs
OK, but I can't see why you would take issue with the term. It's simply a politically correct way to say "mentally retarded" and it is very commonly used. Just because "healthopedia" and "answers.com" don't use it doesn't make it any less correct. ;-)
agree RHELLER : definitely what we would use in the U.S. at this point in time - mentally retarded is considered a no-no
7 hrs
There is no one correct "politically correct" term in use. I think some people are letting competitiveness impede their judgement a bit. Thanks Rita! : )
Something went wrong...
Term search
  • All of ProZ.com
  • Term search
  • Jobs
  • Forums
  • Multiple search