May 19, 2003 17:00
21 yrs ago
English term

sentence

Non-PRO English Art/Literary
YEah, it's like it's karma. My karma. It's like saying "Oh Brian Epstein did die and we did go to America and we did get Apple." It's like everywhere you go you've got a number of choices. You cans ay there is croassroads and you can go left or you can go right.

G. Harrison

I ain't sure what he meant by saying this sentence in inverted commas.

Discussion

Non-ProZ.com May 19, 2003:
note 4 This is all I have,
This is a quote from George Harrison, - an oral utterance written down
Non-ProZ.com May 19, 2003:
note3 I know emphatical constructions. I am asking for the contextual interpretation and not literal translation
Non-ProZ.com May 19, 2003:
note 2 To Fuad Yahaya:
I do not know what he meant, although I get the words. But when I translate that into my mother tomgue, it makes no sense within the context. Translation is not transposing words but ideas. I don't understand the idea, so asking for help
Non-ProZ.com May 19, 2003:
note 1 I simply cannot see the link between the sentnce in inverted commas and the stuff on karma, and the stuff on choices. Nothing comes before it's. That is the whole problem. Before that I have other people (Dezo Hoffman, Allistair Taylor etc) talking on BRian Epstein, his death, and what happened after he died
Refugio May 19, 2003:
IT's like. WHAT's like? What comes before?
Fuad Yahya May 19, 2003:
Where is the difficulty?

Responses

+13
38 mins
Selected

fate

Fate (karma) decreed that Epstein died.
This led to a crossroads for the future of the Beatles, since they no longer had a manager. They chose to go to America, and they also chose to set up the Apple record label.
If Epstein had lived longer, these choices (and their destiny or karma) would have been different. So even in death Epstein affected Harrison's personal karma.
Peer comment(s):

agree David Knowles : This makes it clearer to me!
13 mins
thanks
agree Bin Zhang
24 mins
agree J. Leo (X)
1 hr
agree Oceane
1 hr
agree Marie Scarano
1 hr
agree Natalia Koltsova : Great explanation!
1 hr
Thanks
agree karin förster handley
2 hrs
agree jerrie
3 hrs
agree DGK T-I
5 hrs
agree Refugio : It also may mean that in his life Harrison had both bad karma and good karma, bad consequences and good consequences.
5 hrs
True - on the other hand let's not go into predestination etc
agree Sarah Ponting
13 hrs
agree Gayle Wallimann : Well put.
13 hrs
Thanks
agree A.Đapo
20 hrs
Something went wrong...
4 KudoZ points awarded for this answer.
26 mins

we did get Apple

we received New York (settled there in New York). Hope it helps. Good luck, Lacrimosa! In other senteces emphatical did-cinstructions are used to strengthen the meaning of the verb. Surely the sentences in the inverted commas stress the repetition of obvious facts. It's called "inner monologue", if I'm not mistaken (I mean the whole paragraph).

--------------------------------------------------
Note added at 2003-05-19 17:28:32 (GMT)
--------------------------------------------------

To help you, the whole text is needed. It\'s just some kind of writer\'s style.
Peer comment(s):

agree Bin Zhang
36 mins
Thanx, Bin Zhang!
disagree Refugio : Apple in this sentence means the Beatles' record label.
5 hrs
Punning possible here, I guess. Thanx anyway, Ruth Henderson.
Something went wrong...
+3
35 mins

3 things happened and karma is why

1)Brian Epstein died
2) we went to America
3) we got Apple



Choice and Consequences
One might see "karma" as a continuance of the soul's "personality" from one physical reincarnation to the next - in other words, we carry the same beliefs and habits in our soul's "memory" each time we reincarnate, until we make conscious choices to change old beliefs, cancel mistaken beliefs, or create new ones.

In this lifetime we come as old souls in baby bodies, with all the karma created by the consequences of choices in all our past lives. We are given this lifetime as another opportunity to clear old karma by making different choices in the similar situations we keep creating for ourselves until we get it right.



Karma is just uncorrected errors and lessons yet unlearned. The important thing to remember is that we can choose again. We do not have to remain a "victim" of the karma we created ourselves. We can use our Free Will to make a better choice next time, one that does not create karma to remind us that we made a mistake.

Mistakes require correction, not punishment.

When we learn to make choices which keep us in tune with the spiritual laws of the Universe, we don't create karma. It is like learning not to defy the physical law of Gravity, so we can avoid falling down
Peer comment(s):

agree DGK T-I
5 hrs
agree wendyzee (X) : fully agreed - I don't think the three things are related. Also keep in mind that it was written down from speech and not written as writing - if that makes sense.
10 hrs
agree Sarah Ponting
13 hrs
Something went wrong...
+1
9 hrs

The sentence is in inverted commas

because it's a direct thought, he says it's like saying, so it's treated here like it's a direct quote.
Peer comment(s):

agree Sarah Ponting : that's certainly true, although I still can't work out exactly what it is the asker wants to know...
4 hrs
I agree, hard to answer
Something went wrong...
+1
12 hrs

Variety of karmas

What I understand from the above sentence is that it is the words of some hindu saint describing the variety of karma. The paragraph and phrase are missing here. Karma is that everyone'd do according to shreemadbhagwadgita
Even dying is a karma, karma for soul to get rid of body.
getting apple is like karma of getting, it's my karma to get an apple.
going america here means that going is a karma.
All this may mean that their are variety of karmas. Each and everyone'd stick to his karma and 'd handle it properly and to the best of the efforts.
Whole problem in ur sentences is that unless and untill depth of whole speech is reached, it'll be difficult to say it definitely, what does speaker wants to say.
PRAKAASH
[email protected]

--------------------------------------------------
Note added at 2003-05-20 15:19:17 (GMT)
--------------------------------------------------

in first line read \" these are the words..........\" instead of \"it is the...........\".
May be an exaggerated explanation, but I\'ve tried my best according to the words provided.
PRAKAASH
Peer comment(s):

agree Bin Zhang
18 hrs
Thanks Bin!
Something went wrong...
Term search
  • All of ProZ.com
  • Term search
  • Jobs
  • Forums
  • Multiple search